|One of the problems with the USO Oil ETF is that it doesn't track the underlying
price of oil very well. In fact, the USO ETF (“United States Oil”) closed today
at 33.12 while the price of June West Texas Intermediate Crude closed at 94.50 — that's a whopping
difference for an ETF which is supposed to track the commodity! The problem with USO, which
we've pointed out on various occasions is that the fund has to buy oil one month and, after holding it
for a month, roll it the next month, at a loss of premium if the next month is trading at
a higher price. These losses mount up over time when the commodity is
in a state known as “contango”—which simply means that more distant in time contracts trade
at a premium to nearby contracts. The opposite situation—“backwardation”—occurs
when more distant contracts trade at a discount to nearer-term contracts. During times of backwardation,
the buy-and-hold investor collects a premium bonus every time they roll (sell the expiring contract
and purchase the next one) to the next contract. That can
amount to quite a bit of premium over time.
One interesting thing about bull markets in commodities is that backwardation is often a sign of a bull trend. It isn't necessary that a commodity be in backwardation to be a bull market, but it is a confirming indicator that a bull market is underway. So, it's no wonder oil has not been in backwardation in many years—it has indeed been in a bear market.
Interestingly, there is a market in oil which is in backwardation, but it's the
European Brent Oil contract rather
than the United States Oil contract. And there is an ETF which tracks the Brent contract. Its ticker
is BNO and it has performed well since the Brent contract went into backwardation. Here's
a chart comparing the two ETFs courtesy Yahoo! Finance::
The big difference in the performance of the two ETFs appears to be mainly due to the backwardation in the Brent contract and the contango in the US contract. This suggests that if the US contract were to go into backwardation, the USO would start to close the gap between it and BNO. Alternately, the Brent contract could go into contango, which would eliminate its advantage. If we do get a general commodity bull market going, this is an important point to consider in choosing an ETF route to play the bull market in oil. If one of the underlying contracts is in contango and the other is in backwardation, choose the one in backwardation for long term holding periods. Since the rollover occurs just once per month in each contract, unless you hold the ETF across the monthly rollover date, the performance of the ETF shouldn't be affected by this factor.
Monday, April 29, 2013
Why USO Hasn't Tracked Oil Prices
Posted by Unknown at 19:59